Though the current project started as a series of posts charting my grief journey after the death of my mother, I am no longer actively grieving. Now, the blog charts a conversation in living, mainly whatever I want it to be. This is an activity that goes well with the theme of this blog (updated 2018). The Sense of Doubt blog is dedicated to my motto: EMBRACE UNCERTAINTY. I promote questioning everything because just when I think I know something is concrete, I find out that it’s not.
Hey, Mom! The Explanation.
Here's the permanent dedicated link to my first Hey, Mom! post and the explanation of the feature it contains.
- Bloggery committed by chris tower - 2611.16 - 10:10
- Days ago: MOM = 4155 days ago & DAD = 809 days ago
- New note - On 1807.06, I ceased daily transmission of my Hey Mom feature after three years of daily conversations. I post Hey Mom blog entries on special occasions. I post the days since ("Days Ago") count on my blog each day, and now I have a second count for Days since my Dad died on August 28, 2024. I am now in the same time zone as Google! So, when I post at 10:10 a.m. PDT to coincide with the time of Mom's death, I am now actually posting late, so it's really 1:10 p.m. EDT. But I will continue to use the time stamp of 10:10 a.m. to remember the time of her death and sometimes 13:40 EDT for the time of Dad's death. The blog entry numbering in the title has changed to reflect total Sense of Doubt posts since I began the blog on 0705.04, which include Hey Mom posts, Daily Bowie posts, and Sense of Doubt posts. Hey Mom posts will still be numbered sequentially. New Hey Mom posts will use the same format as all the other Hey Mom posts; all other posts will feature this format seen here.
Anger over the use of AI in art heated up over the weekend after Adi Granov called out DC cover artist Francesco Mattina for using AI in a variant cover for Superman #18.
Granov – a star artist perhaps best known for his Iron Man work – posted the cover in a Facebook post which pulled no punches – especially in relation to the wonky looking S-shield – and even used the H-word.
When image generators first came to prominence the first person who came to mind was the serial plagiarist Francesco Mattina as I thought he’d think all his Christmases have come at once. If you don’t remember, he made a whole career out of photobashing other people’s art (mine included) into whatever you want to call his “work”. I don’t post about artists I dislike, but I neither consider him an artist nor can I hide my dislike for the continued blatant plagiarism. Anyhow, here’s his new cover. Not only is he a hack, but he’s not even good enough to hide the glaring mistake on one of the most iconic symbols in all of pop-culture.
Granov continued in a comment:
Even the S aside, this is just an awful image. Every single detail in it is terrible and super messy. I think I would have to write a whole essay to point out just how badly this was put together, but every element is in the wrong place, badly sized, poorly oriented, etc. Random elements, such as poorly placed giant buttons, earrings, press badge, which don’t exist in the same space as the figure. Even Lex is mirrored with the pocket on the wrong side, not to mention his ear growing out of his cheekbone. But Superman is just a disaster with a dislocated shoulder, that weird leg with random muscles, the cape which is bizarrely much thicker on one side than the other, the disaster of his neck/traps/collarbones/whatever the hell is going on there. Than random pigeons and a castle thrown in with completely illogical starbursts and radial blurs in every which direction to obscure and smudge it all. The S is just the most blatant detail, but make no mistake this really is a genuinely awful bashing of found elements, generated or otherwise.
I never make posts like this, but this guy has been a blight on our industry for so damn long and he seemingly has no remorse as he just keeps on doing it.
It’s fair to say that this error-ridden image fired up a lot of simmering rage that artists are feeling over the use of AI art instead of human effort. Among the more than 300 comments Bill Sienkiewicz, Mico Suayan, Meghan Hetrick, Duncan Rouleau, Jill Thompson, Billy Tucci, Emanuela Lupacchino and many more pros sounded off with brutal put downs.
I want to reiterate that making a negative post like that really goes against my general attitude towards art and artists, but more so it can also be dangerous as it might be perceived as bullying. Not much gets under my skin in such a way, but certain things really need to be called out. Here I am about 10 days into a traditional painting obsessing over every detail, fighting the materials, mixing paints, etc., which is my choice as I want to accomplish something I am proud of and something the audience can view and hopefully see how much skill, care and time I put into it. It won’t be to everyone’s tastes, some might even hate it, but it can’t be denied that I gave it my all.
I am trying to pay respect to the art, the subject matter, to myself and to the audience who I want to be able to have confidence and trust in the authenticity of what they are seeing.
The cover I posted by Francesco Mattina, much like all of his work I’ve ever seen, is a literal antithesis of all of those things. He has had a very long career built upon deceiving the audiences with his cheap digital trickery, using blurs and lensflares to disguise and obscure all of the elements he has stolen from so many of my peers and me included. I am not the first to point this out, it has been discussed many times over the years, but he has always had people defending him even when the evidence was irrefutable.
This isn’t just about him. When I was a much younger artist and much less aware of such things, I saw an Arthur Suydam zombie Silver Surfer cover and immediately recognised the surfboard as just copied and pasted from one of my covers, texture, lighting, everything just as I painted it, with only the areas where I had the Surfer standing smudged badly to disguise it. I couldn’t believe it, a “legendary” artists just wholesale stealing something I spent all this time creating. He wasn’t inspired by it, he didn’t use it as reference, he didn’t homage it, he just stole the whole thing from someone trying to make their way into the industry. Purely out of laziness, or a lack of skill, or any of the other things which mean you aren’t qualified for the job. I wasn’t quiet about it at the time, but that image is still out there published as both the cover and prints.
So back to Mattina. I don’t want to bully him or cause him harm, but he is making a mockery, and has been his entire career, out of all of us. He’s selling you a flashy piece of trash created without any care, skill or honesty. He’s just trying to deceive everyone for reasons only known to him. In my view work like that is hugely damaging to the industry, to the companies he works for, to all of us artists who actually care but then have our art stolen and repurposed. It’s sad that only such an obvious oversight such as the double S on Superman seems to have finally been irrefutable, but it’s the perfect example of how little he cares. Even if he is using Al, or if he is stealing other people’s work, even if Al is the future, as so many claim, then at least do it well. But he is even awful at cheating and couldn’t see that the literal main element of the whole cover, the Superman logo, is messed up. That is not a mistake, that is pure oversight on his part where his cheating slipped through as he was too lazy to even look at his “creation” to make sure the most basic of elements are correct.
He cares so little for the art and the audience that he can’t even put effort in to cheat well.
I don’t wish him or anyone like him any harm, but I also want the harm they are doing to all of us to stop. I could think of dozens of my artists friends trying to break into the industry who could have done a much better and far more honest job. It’s damaging to them as much as it’s dishonest to the fans and to the artists he has stolen from over the years. It must be really disheartening for a young artist, like I was back with that Silver Surfer, to keep motivated when you are seemingly competing with someone making a total mockery of the things you believe in.
As Granov indicated, Mattina has a long history of being accused of swiping – Alex Garnercalled him out for swiping a fee years ago, as did artist Lee JeeHyung. And that’s not all. There’s a long Twitter thread also enumerating many times when Mattina was accused of swiping – including by an art director at Sideshow Toys.
And publishers were aware of Mattina’s rep as a swiper, as reported in a comment by former Marvel Talent Coordinator Bon Alimagno:
Years back when I was still at Marvel, CB comes into a meeting with a printed out gallery of Mattina’s work. And one of Marvel’s lead cover artists at the time had circled specific portions of every cover, to go on the record with what he thought Mattina had swiped from him, and sent that to CB to print out. Mattina had sent Marvel and the artist apologies already before that review, but he didn’t get cover work with Marvel for years after that, maybe not since then. Surprised he actually still does with anybody. And this was in 2010.
Whew. There’s a lot to unpack here.
Starting with a niggling detail, as far as that Superman symbol goes, not only does it have two tails, but the thing that bothers me about it is that it’s way off center – it seems to be floating off Superman’s chest, and the tail is pointing to his right hip, not his belt buckle. Here’s a photo of Henry Cavill where you can see the S-shield does shift a bit…..but not that much. As Granov points out, the way all the elements of the image are constructed they just don’t fit together.
Next, it’s rare to see such a unified outpouring of frustration from the comics industry on any topic. Publishers have been hiring known swipe artists (cough Greg Land cough) for years, but the current onslaught of AI – bringing with it layoffs of actual humans – has created a fraught atmosphere of anxiety. AI is still pretty bad at search, but it’s pretty good at generating pretty images, and improving all the time. But as Granov put it, it’s “selling you a flashy piece of trash created without any care, skill or honesty.” When something like this slips through, it’s concerning.
And how did this slip through? Mattina’s rep is no secret, are editors at DC really that desperate?
Just guessing here, but…..they probably are. Take a look at the September solicits. So many variant covers. So many pin-ups. So many, many pin-ups. I doubt we’ll ever go back to covers like this,
but it would be a bit harder for AI to churn out these kinds of images. (Or maybe not.)
Having once, long ago, been a monthly comics editor, I’m sympathetic to the looming terror of the empty page. Mattina is probably always on time and a heck of a guy….so he gets work. To my very untrained eye, these covers look blatantly AI-generated – maybe not the whole thing but at least parts of the image composition. But if I were on a tight deadline, I might not look as closely as I should.
So what happens next? A few months ago, DC pulled some covers by artist Daxiong after he was accused of using AI. (And those covers were way better than the Mattina ones.) I expect we’ll soon hear the same about these Mattina covers. Clearly, more oversight or quality control is needed as AI-generated images become more and more prevalent. Some people have called for the return of an Art Director at DC, a position once held by Mark Chiarello, before he was removed in one of DC’s endless rounds of layoffs. There is, sadly, only one Chi, but even so, that kind of position might not even work in today’s comics world – especially at DC which is still running with a cut to the bone staff.
The things is…there are so many talented human artists out there. I saw some kids at an SVA event last month who could do better, fresher, more interesting covers than Mattina’s. Scrolling through this months solicits, I see some striking work by top-notch creators. And I see a few pot-boilers. Don’t hate the player, hate the game.
The issue of AI-generated art is certainly not going away, and it’s cropping up everywhere. Who knows, maybe AI will create jobs…finding people who can spot it and call it out when the results are as sloppy as this.
- Bloggery committed by chris tower - 2611.15 - 10:10
- Days ago: MOM = 4154 days ago & DAD = 808 days ago
- New note - On 1807.06, I ceased daily transmission of my Hey Mom feature after three years of daily conversations. I post Hey Mom blog entries on special occasions. I post the days since ("Days Ago") count on my blog each day, and now I have a second count for Days since my Dad died on August 28, 2024. I am now in the same time zone as Google! So, when I post at 10:10 a.m. PDT to coincide with the time of Mom's death, I am now actually posting late, so it's really 1:10 p.m. EDT. But I will continue to use the time stamp of 10:10 a.m. to remember the time of her death and sometimes 13:40 EDT for the time of Dad's death. The blog entry numbering in the title has changed to reflect total Sense of Doubt posts since I began the blog on 0705.04, which include Hey Mom posts, Daily Bowie posts, and Sense of Doubt posts. Hey Mom posts will still be numbered sequentially. New Hey Mom posts will use the same format as all the other Hey Mom posts; all other posts will feature this format seen here.
A Sense of Doubt blog post #4289 - Is it Because it's Cringe? Gen Z Loves Felicity
I love the Felicity program and surely my adoration for it was probably more about Keri Russell than it being JJ Abrams' first TV show, despite the initial scandal that he was like a fifteen year old girl or something like that, which turned out to be a writer on the show and not Abrams who falsely claimed she was "an up and coming nineteen year old."
I am excited that Gen Z is embracing this superb program, and I can't disagree that Felicity Porter is a little cringe but at the same time empowering.
Sure, she followed a boy across the country and chucked her plans (more her parents' plans) for a new path. Ultimately, the show is about the character becoming who she is destined to be, growing up, and less about which guy she's going to end up with.
SPOILER - BEWARE
(The answer is Ben, paying off on the promise of the show's premise in a weird alternate future vision experience).
I loved it.
I was there for it.
I may need to return to it.
Thanks for tuning in.
Felicity Porter is messy, earnest and a little cringe. Her Gen Z fans are here for it.
She followed a boy to college. That’s the least interesting thing about her.
In the final moments of the Felicity pilot, Felicity Porter (Keri Russell) is having dinner with her parents at a fancy restaurant in New York City. Convinced she's made a grave mistake by moving to the Big Apple on a whim, her parents urge — and even try to bribe — her to return home to Palo Alto, Calif., and pursue medicine as planned. Felicity is quiet, seemingly weighing her options in real time before mustering the courage to speak. "I guess the thing is," she begins. "That if I made a mistake… then at least it was mine, you know?"
The scene is short but pivotal — and captures the essence of the show. Created by J.J. Abrams and Matt Reeves, Felicity, which ran from 1998 to 2002,is a coming-of-age series about a soft-spoken teen who derails her college plans after one conversation with her longtime crush. The series has found a new generation of fans since arriving on Netflix in October.
After speaking to Ben Covington (Scott Speedman) for the first time at their high school graduation, Felicity abandons her plans to attend Stanford and instead follows him across the country to the (fictional) University of New York. Does she have a clue what she's doing? Hardly. For many first-time Gen Z viewers, her decision to prioritize a guy is pretty cringe.
And yet, Felicity has managed to captivate this wave of new, younger viewers anyway, emerging as something of an inspiration — however unhinged she may be.
"A lot of it is just the everyday struggles of a college girl figuring out her life, rather than the over-the-top, sometimes unrealistic high school and college dramas we see today," Alexa, 28, told Yahoo. "I think there's something really nice about watching a show where the little things in life are enough to make a story interesting."
A lesson in following your heart
Felicity demonstrates just how willing she is to put herself out there — and how in tune she is with her own feelings over the course of the series. Is it kind of rash to follow someone you have a crush on to college? Absolutely. But that's what makes her so compelling to younger audiences: She does the big, scary thing.
Camila, 28, told Yahoo that while some of Felicity's decisions have "definitely" been "a hard watch," she understands them. "Personally, I've done some questionable things when having a crush on someone," she said. "I think that aspect resonates a lot with people."
Shadon, 25, said Felicity's vulnerability is what drew her to the character. There's something to be said about a young woman who goes after what she wants regardless of what anyone thinks.
"A lesson I learned from Felicity herself is that it's OK to be honest about how I'm feeling," she told Yahoo. "So many characters in the modern landscape hold back how they really feel to keep up a certain facade, but Felicity is always willing to put it all out there."
Her willingness to go after what she wants extends beyond romance. Ben might have been the reason she moved to New York — but he isn't why she stayed. "Felicity has definitely taught me to follow my heart more," Chelsea, 25, told Yahoo. "It might not always work out but I think you can learn a lot about yourself when leading with your heart rather than your head all the time. Moving to New York quickly became so much bigger than chasing some boy."
She also isn't afraid to defy her parents. Felicity's career path has been mapped out for as long as she can remember — graduate high school, attend Stanford as a premed student, continue on to medical school and so on — but it wasn't what she wanted. Not immediately, anyway. She needed the space to figure things out.
"I really enjoyed how much emphasis the show put on her not having her life plan figured out, even when she was in her last year of college," Shadon added. "Felicity was constantly shown changing career paths and having no idea of what she wanted to do once she graduated, which I could definitely relate to."
Davey Chafe, a clinical psychologist, told Yahoo that Felicity's desire for independence reflects a process known as separation and individuation, which happens during late adolescence and early adulthood. It's essentially a period of flux.
"It's basically when we are learning who we are outside of our family and our caregivers, so our main family unit," Chafe said. Felicity even articulates the lack of control she's had over her own life when the show begins. She notes early on that her dad was "thrilled" she got into Stanford because he "had my life planned out for me since I was pretty much a zygote."
"Especially at that age, the decisions we're making during that period are really driven a bit more by emotion and kind of trial and error than logic," Chafe said. "I think that's a pretty accurate reflection of what growing up can feel like."
Standing up for what's right
Maria DiPasquale, a longtime Felicity fan and founder of Leftist Teen Drama, a podcast that celebrates political moments in teen TV, cites a Season 2 storyline as one of the show's most important.
In "Revolutions," the season's 16th episode, Felicity helps stage a sit-in at the student health center after learning the university's board of trustees has banned the morning-after pill. Despite mounting pressure from the school to stand down, she forges ahead with the days-long protest. The board eventually reverses its ban after Julie (Amy Jo Johnson), Felicity's best friend, reveals she used the pill after being sexually assaulted on campus.
When a television show makes a concerted effort to spotlight political issues that affect young people, DiPasquale told Yahoo, she's "gonna give them their flowers." She hopes the episode encourages new viewers to take action in their communities.
"I think it's a really timeless message," she said. "I really hope that young people are inspired by the plot line and realize that they also have the power to do what Felicity and her friends do and they can win. Any injustice on your campus, in your school, in your workplace — you have the power in working with other people, with other students, to put your heads together and figure out how you can make injustice go away."
Romanticizing a pre-social media existence
As a younger millennial, watching Felicity makes me feel as though I've been transported to a completely different time. Felicity swears by her tape recorder, which we see her use in the show's opening minutes. She goes to the library to conduct research for her college papers. She runs to pay phones to make urgent calls and even leaves her dorm room to have face-to-face conversations with other people.
There's an instant gratification that social media and modern technology afford us — an immediacy that didn't exist in the 1990s. Felicity, for instance, is someone who sits in her feelings a lot. I can't imagine that'd be as easy if she had Instagram at her fingertips.
"There's something really comforting about watching relationships unfold where people aren't constantly accessible to one another. I think that it just gives people a little more space, right? Which you can feel in the show," Chafe said. "I think for younger people, part of the comfort is seeing everyone navigate the awkwardness, uncertainty and intensity of growing up without feeling like every moment is being watched."
Felicity recording a tape for her friend Sally.
(laguna_biotch/Threads)
The show's analog, pre-social media existence is something Gen Z viewers yearn for. Chelsea told Yahoo that "it is so rare to see someone be so completely free" in the age of social media. Now, she said, "we are all desperate to appear polished and we put on personas to appear cooler on the internet."
"It's refreshing to see a version of college life that's still so relatable to what we experience today, but without phones and social media being such a big part of it," Alexa said. "It almost feels like an escape, especially now that technology and social media seem to find their way into every show we watch."
Chafe hopes Felicity will inspire younger audiences to spend more time offline. "We've never been more connected but also never been more lonely," he said. "If people are connecting to the show there's a reason, and I think part of the reason is that it does feel a bit more human."
Living like you're the main character
For all her quirks and flaws and rash decisions, Felicity keeps learning to trust herself. That's not to say she hasn't considered stifling her own wants to appease others, but her struggle to prioritize her feelings is part of what makes her so relatable. It's another reason Gen Z viewers feel connected to her: She gives main-character energy.
"Felicity lives her life like she's the main character, and personally, I think that's how everyone should live," Alexa said. "I think there's something really refreshing about watching someone who isn't afraid to take herself and her feelings seriously, even if it makes her look ridiculous sometimes."
At a time when social media makes it easier to hide what we're actually feeling, Felicity reminds us there's merit in being exactly who you are, regardless of what anyone thinks. There's something deeply human about her hesitation and fear of hurting others, even as she finds the courage to put herself first. Perhaps there's something to be said about being a little bit cringe and taking a chance: It could be worth it in the long run.
- Bloggery committed by chris tower - 2611.14 - 10:10
- Days ago: MOM = 4153 days ago & DAD = 807 days ago
- New note - On 1807.06, I ceased daily transmission of my Hey Mom feature after three years of daily conversations. I post Hey Mom blog entries on special occasions. I post the days since ("Days Ago") count on my blog each day, and now I have a second count for Days since my Dad died on August 28, 2024. I am now in the same time zone as Google! So, when I post at 10:10 a.m. PDT to coincide with the time of Mom's death, I am now actually posting late, so it's really 1:10 p.m. EDT. But I will continue to use the time stamp of 10:10 a.m. to remember the time of her death and sometimes 13:40 EDT for the time of Dad's death. The blog entry numbering in the title has changed to reflect total Sense of Doubt posts since I began the blog on 0705.04, which include Hey Mom posts, Daily Bowie posts, and Sense of Doubt posts. Hey Mom posts will still be numbered sequentially. New Hey Mom posts will use the same format as all the other Hey Mom posts; all other posts will feature this format seen here.