A Sense of Doubt blog post #2044 - Labor Based Grading and the contract
42 DAYS - VOTE
I am going to start having a count down to vote in my blogs.
Two of my colleagues and I are trying a special type of grading contract system in some of our college classes at Lower Columbia College called LABOR BASED GRADING.
Here's some materials about it in this entry,
It's mainly championed by a very cool teacher by the name of Asao B. Inoue, who teaches for Arizona State University:
https://asaobinoue.blogspot.com/
I am happy to report that in reading the "about" link on his blog, I see that he is a kindred spirit in what he reads and his playing of Dungeons and Dragons.
FROM INOUE'S Blog:
Growing up, I was also a remedial English student in elementary and junior high school, despite my loving to read, and reading lots of science fiction and fantasy novels. Some of my favorite authors at the time were Tolkien, Asimov, Bradley, Brooks, McCaffrey, and LeGuin.
By the time I reached sixth grade, my brother and I found Dungeons and Dragons, and we were hooked on the game until college. The game give me a strong grounding in doing research, creating worlds, stories, and characters with language. It was also a deeply satisfying daily literacy practice that was collaborative and rewarding, something I shared with my twin brother, Tad. Today, we still play every now and then. We've moved to the Pathfinder system.
Here's what I said to my classes.
Coreq Camp 2020: Labor Based Grading in the ALP Corequisite Model
Mark Blaauw-Hara, who has been teaching in the ALP model since 2012, will describe how he has adapted Asao Inoue’s labor-based grading framework for use in the co-requisite classroom. Inoue has argued that labor-based grading contracts are especially useful when working with first-generation college students and students of color who may feel disconnected from more traditional grading strategies; he has also argued that labor-based grading can be an essential part of anti-racist writing assessment. Blaauw-Hara has found that labor-based grading is particularly effective in co-requisite writing classrooms, which typically contain students who have an uneasy relationship with more “standard” models of teaching and assessing writing. Blaauw-Hara will discuss his rationale, share his own grading contracts, and help participants identify possible ways they may build labor-based grading into their own classes.
North Central Michigan College: Petoskey, Michigan
HERE IS THE CONTRACT FOR THE COURSE:
edited for Spring 2021 - 2104.08
GRADING CONTRACT – TOWER – SPRING 2021 –
ENGLISH 101 – LCC
I
offer this contract that focuses on the responsibilities we’ll assume, not the
things to which someone else (usually the teacher) will hold you accountable.
The pedagogical shift I’m suggesting is in part a cultural one, one that I
would like you to control. Therefore, we will try to approximate the evaluative conditions of a home studio course. That
is, we will try to create a culture of support, or rather a community of compassion, a group of
people who genuinely care about the wellbeing of each other – and part of that
caring, that compassion, is doing things for each other. It turns out, this
also helps you learn. The best way to learn is to teach others, to help, to
serve. So we will function as collaborators, allies, as fellow-travelers with
various skills, abilities, experiences, and talents that we offer the group,
rather than adversaries working against each other for grades or a teacher’s
approval.
Do
not worry. You will get lots of assessments on your writing and other work
during the semester from your colleagues and me. Use these assessments to
rethink ideas and improve your writing and practices, to take risks, in short
to fail and learn from that failing. Always know that I will read everything
and shape our classroom assessment activities and discussions around your work,
but you will not receive grades from me.
I want you not only to rely on your colleagues and yourself for assessment and
revision advice but to build strategies of self-assessment that function apart
from a teacher’s approval.
Therefore
the default grade for the course is a “B” (3.0).
In
a nutshell, if you do all that is asked of you in the manner and spirit it is asked,
if you work through the processes we establish and the work we assign ourselves
in the labor instructions during the quarter, if you do all the labor asked of
you, then you’ll get a “B” course grade. It will not matter what I or your
colleagues think of your writing. We may disagree or misunderstand your
writing, but if you put in the labor that meets requirements to qualify as
sufficient labor, you are guaranteed a B course grade. If you miss class (do
not participate fully), turn in assignments late, forget to do assignments, or
do not follow the labor instructions, you will get a lower course grade (see
the grading table below).
“B”
Grades
You are guaranteed a course grade of
“B” (3.0) if you meet all of the following conditions.
- Sharing and Collaboration. You agree to work cooperatively and collegially in
groups. This may be the easiest of all our course expectations to figure
out, but we should have some discussions on what we expect from each
other.
- Late/Incomplete Work. You agree to turn in properly and on time all work
and assignments expected of you in the spirit they are assigned, which
means you’ll complete all of the labor instructions for each assignment.
During the semester, you may, however, turn in a few assignments late. The
exact number of those late assignments is stipulated in the table below,
which we negotiate. Late or incomplete
work is defined as any work or document due that is turned in AFTER the
due date/time BUT within 48 hours of the deadline. For example, if
some work was due on Thursday at 11:59 pm, then that piece must be turned
in by 11:59 pm on the Saturday following to be within the grace period. For
some assignments, such as peer review or an essay draft due for a
conference, then the 48-grace period may not apply. The instructor will
notify students of these exceptions.
- Missed Work.
Work that is not submitted AFTER
the 48 hours grace period stipulated in #2 above (Late/Incomplete
Work), then it will be considered “missed work,” which is a more serious
mark against your grading contract. All assignments build upon each other
(and are sometimes used to construct future lessons), and so turning in
something beyond 48 hours after it is due means it is assured to be less
useful for you and your colleagues in the class. You agree not to ignore any
work expected of you. Ignored work is any work unaccounted for in the
quarter – that is, I have no record of you doing it or turning it in: same
as missed work but more of a conscious choice. My sense is that ignoring
the work so crucial to one’s development as a learner in our community is
bad and unacceptable, so accumulating any “ignored work” will keep you
from meeting our contract expectations (see GRADING CONTRACT TABLE).
- INCOMPLETE STATUS. A student might submit work and yet earn an
“incomplete” status due to missing important requirements key to the
work’s completion. When an instructor grants an incomplete, he will
communicate the means to convert the incomplete status to complete status if
such conversion is allowed for that work. If it is not possible to “fix”
the incomplete condition, then the incomplete status counts the same as an
“incomplete” due to work that was missed or ignored.
- ESSAY PROCESS WORK. Most of these rules in the contract apply to
assignments, class periods, and journals; however, the core work of the
course is to write THREE ESSAYS and to earn complete for all at the end of
the quarter (see separate section on FINAL ASSESSMENT OF THE PORTFOLIO).
However, because writing is a process, each essay will consist of multiple
steps in the essay process, work stages that are set up in Canvas as assignments
but are not counted in the total for assignments in the grading contract table
but are part of the essay category in which each number represents a complete
status for the entire process. If a student earns “incomplete” in any of
the steps in the process, then the entire process has incomplete status.
As with assignments, an incomplete may be earned due to missing/ignoring a
step in the process or missing key requirements in the completion of the
step necessary to earn a complete. In all cases, when the instructor
awards an “incomplete” for steps in the essay process, he will communicate
the ways in which the student may convert the step to complete, the
timeline for doing so, and the consequences for not doing the work to
convert the process to complete (termination of the contract or some other
consequence).
- Conferences.
Four times throughout the quarter, you will be asked to schedule an individual
meeting with instructor to discuss your work and progress in the class.
These conferences are designed to be collaborative conversations about
your goals and the direction your labor and thinking can go in order to
help you reach these goals. These
conferences are an incredibly important component of the class. Therefore, you cannot miss one of the
four conferences and still receive a passing grade in the class (C or
above). If something comes up which
means you are unable to attend your scheduled conference, you must reach
out to me within 24 hours to reschedule.
A rescheduled conference is not a “missed” conference. A conference is only considered “missed”
if you do not reach out to me within 24 hours, or if you also fail to
attend the rescheduled conference.
- All Work/Labor needs to meet the following conditions. To be complete
and On Time, you agree to turn in on time and in the appropriate
manner complete essays, writing, or other labor assigned that meet all of
our agreed upon expectations. This means you’ll carefully follow ALL of the LABOR INSTRUCTIONS
given for the assignment, and be honest about completing labor that asks
for particular time commitments of you (for example, “write for 20
minutes,” etc.).
- Gimme. A “Gimme” is a waiver of a
late or missed assignment. You may
use a gimme for any reason, but only once in the semester. At the
final conference of the quarter, the administrator of our contract will
decide in consultation with each individual student how to best apply
their “gimme.” A gimme is NOT an
“out clause” for anyone who happens to not fulfill the contract in some
way; it is for rare and unusual circumstances out of the control of the
student. It can be used to move one item in any of the columns in the
above table to a lesser mark on your contract. For instance, take one
ignored assignment and make it a missed, or 1 missed and turn it into a
late, or take 1 late assignment off your record.
GIMME
CONTINUED: If there are true emergency
situations that may warrant one additional
“gimme,” this can be negotiated in our final conference at the end of the term.
Our primary concern will be to make decisions that are fair and equitable to
all in the class while still meeting the college’s requirements for workload in
classes. Please keep in mind that the contract is a public, social contract, one
agreed upon through group discussion and negotiation, so my job is to make sure
that whatever agreement we come to about a plea will not be unfair to others in
class.
- FINAL
ASSESSMENT OF THE PORTFOLIO: Even
though the student earns no
grades and accumulates no points throughout the quarter, Lower Columbia
College expects a final grade to be awarded using the traditional letter
grade system at the end of the quarter. The system for awarding the final
letter grade is spelled out throughout this contract and clearly in
GRADING CONTRACT TABLE elsewhere in the document. However, the Final Portfolio
comprises the final chance for a student to earn a complete for each of the
three essay processes, all three of which are needed to be complete to
earn the grade of B promised in the contract. Though the instructor will
communicate how a student earns complete in each essay process in the
essay process module/assignments for that process, the final essays must
sufficiently pass assessment of the course outcomes shared in the COURSE
DESCRIPTION DOCUMENT to earn complete status in the final assessment.
PLEASE NOTE the caveat following the GRADING CONTRACT TABLE stipulating
that a student’s final draft of ESSAY THREE and the entire ESSAY THREE
PROCESS must earn complete to make the student eligible to pass the
course, even if the other two processes earn complete making the student
eligible for a grade of C.
- CONTRACT
TERMINATION: The instructor reserves the right to terminate a
student’s contract at any point in the quarter for failing to complete the
required work in a timely fashion or due to any violations of the LCC
student code of conduct. The instructor promises to work with students to
get back on track and succeed if they struggle and to warn students -- at
least once -- of a potential contract termination before actually
terminating the contract. If the instructor terminates a contract, then
the student will not be able to pass the course and should drop if the
termination precedes the withdrawal date.
GRADING CONTRACT TABLE
Labor-Based
Grading Contract
|
A |
B |
C |
D or below |
Essays*** |
3 |
3 |
2 |
1 or fewer |
Journals**** |
14-13+ |
12 |
11-10 |
9 or fewer |
Assignments |
12+ |
11-10 |
9 |
8 or fewer |
Conferences** |
4 |
4 |
4 |
3 or fewer |
Portfolio |
1 |
1 |
1 |
0 |
Attendance* |
10 |
9 |
8 |
7 or fewer |
*Basic attendance expectations are based on asynchronous, online
learning. The attendance number represents the week in full, which is usually
two class periods. Attendance is earned
in asynchronous classes via submission of the “attendance condition” as
outlined in the posted class period page in Canvas. RULES FOR SYNCHRONOUS CLASSES: Attendance is earned by meeting the
daily attendance condition and being present the majority of the class period.
Tardiness may affect earning the attendance condition. Only two missed classes
per quarter can be made up through viewing of the live recording and submitting
detailed notes the instructor and only if requested by the student. Extra
assignments can also be used to convert two and no more than two missed classes
to complete status.
**Conferences need to be made a priority. Students should arrange
their personal schedules accordingly. If you know that you cannot make one of
these dates, let me know ASAP to reschedule. Last minute accommodations may not
be possible with our given timeframe. True emergencies are always the
exception.
*** Student must receive a complete on
the essay three process to pass the course.
**** JOURNAL ASSESSMENTS will be made
after week three, week six, week eight, and week ten. The number in the
contract grid represents a composite of both complete status earned for both
written journal entries and completion checks known as "journal
peeks." So, there are 10 journal entry assignments (one a week) and FOUR
peeks for a total of 14 assessed events for the quarter. Thus, for a grade of B
a student needs only earn 12 completes, which ideally represents all ten
entries and two peeks.
**** JOURNAL ASSESSMENTS continued…
However, if a student skips an entry or earns incomplete on it and
does not fix it, then the student would need complete status on three peeks
(9+3 = 12). Regardless, a student must have two of the four peeks earn
complete. Even if a student completes extra assignments, two of four of the
total number of completes must be in two of the journal peeks. INCOMPLETE: An
incomplete in a journal peek will be given for either or both of the following
reasons: not having enough entries complete by the time of the peek (looking in
week four, three entries would be completed) or if an entry does not meet the
requirements of the prompt. THE FIX: a student may revise an entry that was
attempted but earned incomplete but may not "catch up" on missing
entries to earn the complete status after the peek assessment has been
completed by the instructor.
“CH-CH-CHH-CHANGES” as Mr. Bowie said.
AS this is the
first quarter in which I have employed this grading contract, I reserve the
right to change any of its rules and parameters if I discover a serious flaw in
the construction of the contract and how it affects the work. As administrator,
I have final say on these changes; however, in the spirit of fairness, I will
first PROPOSE the change, open the change to discussion, listen fairly to
objections to the change, and then implement a version of the change, possibly
taking into account the discussion of the proposed change.
Improving Your Contracted Grade
The grade of B (3.0) depends primarily on behavior and labor. Have
you shown responsible effort and consistency in our class? Have you done what
was asked of you in the spirit it was asked? Have you put in the appropriate
amount of labor? Higher grades than the default require more labor that helps
or supports the class in its mutual learning. In order to raise your grade, you
may complete as many of the following items of labor as you like. Each item
completed fully and in the appropriate manner will raise your final course
grade by half a grade category. In other words, completing one extra labor will
raise your letter grade to a plus (+).
Two extra labors will raise your grade to the next letter category (from
a B to an A, from a C to a B, etc.). I
will not give minus (-) grades. ANOTHER WAY to view EXTRAS is that they replace
missed/incomplete or assessed incomplete classes, assignments, or journals,
much like the use of the gimme.
● Exemplary labor. If by our final
meeting conference (end of quarter), you have no late, missed, or ignored
assignments, and do not use a gimme, then you will earn an extra half grade
category (equal to one extra labor item) to your final course grade. This rule
is meant to reward those students who engage in all the labor of the course in
the fullest spirit asked of them and demonstrate themselves to be exemplary
class citizens.
● A lesson and activity for the class:
These lessons are on a topic and material that you research for the class’s benefit
and will need at least two weeks lead time, working with me on the materials.
While we’ll determine together the scope of your lesson, the main elements of
your labor will be to produce: (1) a multi-page handout (or video lesson) for
the class’s benefit in our writing and thinking; (2) an activity that your
classmates can do to engage with the material you present in your lesson; (3) a
video that introduces your lesson and activity; and (3) a short reflective
essay to me of at least 500 words on what you learned in the process of doing
this labor and what you feel the class stands to gain from the lesson you
offered us.
● Announced Extras, such as extra Peer Review:
Throughout the quarter, I will announce extras that can be earned, such as
writing extra peer reviews for classmates.
● EXTRA JOURNALS: The instructor will
share a series of extra journal entries for which you must write five and meet
the length and content requirements to earn this extra. One extra journal may
be of your own design if approved by the instructor. Only one extra can be
earned via extra journals.
● EXTRA PARTIALS THAT ADD UP: The
instructor will reveal many extra partials that add up to a single extra. The
magic number to add is 10 partials equaling one extra. Only one extra can be
earned via totaled partials.
● PROPOSE SOMETHING: Some other labor
that benefits the class and our mutual learning. Propose an idea to the
instructor for approval. For instance, one team of two students did a weekly
podcast in Fall of 2020, a huge task.
● It is YOUR responsibility to keep track
of your extras and extra partials to cash in at the end of the quarter.
For every item you complete on the above list, your contracted grade
will improve by half a grade category on the breakdown table below. So if you
meet all the conditions for a B-contract (3.0), then your grade can improve in
the following ways:
●
1 item completed = course grade of B+
●
2 items completed = course grade of A-
●
3 items completed = course grade of A
●
4 or more items completed = just you being awesome.
Students starting with grades of B may increase their grades to an A.
Students starting with a C may only raise their grades to a B and no higher.
Students who start from a D or F due to missed elements of the contract may not
improve their grades with extras.
OFFICIAL POLICY RE: EXTRAS AND ESSAY
PROCESSES: Extra
assignments make up for missed or incomplete assignments and journals (and
maybe missed classes) but cannot be used to convert a writing process to
complete, which can only be achieved through completion of all steps in the
process and a successful revised draft of the essay. HOWEVER, though an extra
assignment does not convert an INCOMPLETE essay process to a COMPLETE for the
entire process, in some cases, the instructor MAY allow an extra to replace a
missed step in the essay process. These provisions are assessed on a
case-by-case basis.
CAVEAT EXCELSIOR PRIMUS: The instructor
reserves the right to use extras to ameliorate grades in ways beneficial to the
students not outlined in these policies.
AGREEMENT
By staying in this course and attending class, and by clicking on the
confirmation form in Canvas, you certify that you accept this contract and
agree to abide by it. I (chris tower) also agree to abide by the contract, and
administer it fairly and equitably.
Actually, I am thrilled.
I am joking.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
- Bloggery committed by chris tower - 2009.22 - 10:10
- Days ago = 1908 days ago
- New note - On 1807.06, I ceased daily transmission of my Hey Mom feature after three years of daily conversations. I plan to continue Hey Mom posts at least twice per week but will continue to post the days since ("Days Ago") count on my blog each day. The blog entry numbering in the title has changed to reflect total Sense of Doubt posts since I began the blog on 0705.04, which include Hey Mom posts, Daily Bowie posts, and Sense of Doubt posts. Hey Mom posts will still be numbered sequentially. New Hey Mom posts will use the same format as all the other Hey Mom posts; all other posts will feature this format seen here.
No comments:
Post a Comment