Hey, Mom! The Explanation.

Here's the permanent dedicated link to my first Hey, Mom! post and the explanation of the feature it contains.

Thursday, November 11, 2021

A Sense of Doubt blog post #2459 - Examples with James Joyce's "Araby": How to Write Literary Analysis



A Sense of Doubt blog post #2459 - Examples with James Joyce's "Araby": How to Write Literary Analysis, part two

So, I might have mentioned this situation recently.

My students are writing a literary analysis essay on the novel Watchmen or if they choose, comparing a hero's story in Watchmen to the hero story in Binti based on the ideas of archetypal hero myth:

A Sense of Doubt blog post #1576 - Hero's Journey

This is essentially part three of a series to provide them with materials and ideas, but I am calling it part two.

I did the first part here:

A Sense of Doubt blog post #2450 - How to write a literary analysis essay

I did some brainstorming, though arguably I ran out of time to do what I wanted with the brainstorming:

A Sense of Doubt blog post #2451 - WATCHMEN Brainstorming - Writing a Literary Analysis about the Watchmen novel for College Composition

and I did some modeling with "Lady Lazarus" by Sylvia Plath and in class with "The Second Coming" by WB Yeats:

A Sense of Doubt blog post #2456 - Sylvia Plath's "Lady Lazarus" - partial reprint - for teaching ANALYSIS

So, that's a lot of parts. So, this is part five? That's too many. I am calling it part two of #2450 as both are more generally on writing literary analysis.

What currently flummoxes my students is that I am expecting them to have ideas of their own, and that's not what we have been doing.

ESSAY ONE was a response to an article that I gave them. I gave them the article, the question to answer in forming their thesis, and basically a paragraph-by-paragraph breakdown of the essay, not that all of them followed that breakdown. You know, not by coming up with something better, but by ignoring it. You know: TLDR.

ESSAY TWO followed the same pattern in a sense. Now, they have to find their own article to respond to, but it's still helping them choose their subject. My instructions broke down this work draft-by-draft. This essay is the classic persuasive essay.

ESSAY THREE, our current project, asks them to choose a direction to analyze, and I gave them VERY LITTLE instructions. They can either choose a theme, a character, an idea, a chapter to analyze; or they can choose to compare and contrast (C&C) two characters in Watchmen. The third choice is as I mentioned before the C&C of the two books and hero myth.

And I am getting questions, like "I have no idea what to write about."

I modeled the most obvious theme with brainstorming in post #2451 -- the theme of time -- and provided a list of possible ideas that I showed in class. 

I created this progression on purpose.

Now, we see how well they can read and have thoughts.

Granted, I did not "scaffold" this work as much as the others. Then again, I did not want to spoon feed them either. I want them to have thoughts.

And of course, they can GOOGLE: "literary analysis Watchmen."

The first result is an essay from BU analyzing morality in Watchmen:


Not bad.

Here's the thesis:

By understanding and piecing together the unique positions collected in Watchmen, taking into account the recurring motifs and symbols as well, a completely new perspective is born: there is no moral justification for killing, only the justifications that individuals place upon it.

Really not bad.

There's other stuff, too. I just raided the works cited of that article.

Most of the rest of what I am finding I already have.

In any case, I want to be acquainted with whatever they might find because of course I want original work, which is why I have shied away from too much analysis of Watchmen thus far as I want them to find their own ideas and make their own analysis without too much influence.

And so, I have tried to show them literary analysis with OTHER stories or poems; thus, here, I am sharing material about James Joyce's story "Araby" for review.

I used to teach "Araby" back when I used the St. Martin's Guide to Writing, and so these essays one by a student, Sally Crane, and one by a professor, David Ratinov, are familiar and very instructive for showing student what a literary analysis looks like and how to construct.

But wait, that's not all... :-)

I said I was going to make a video, but I am waffling. I have a lot of grading to do and videos take a lot of time.

These essays and the explanations that follow show great examples of literary analysis. I have two more samples following those and neither of them are very good in comparison to the Crane and Ratinov essays. Both of the essays following the photos of the St. Martin's text are very surface level interpretations of the story.

They are good comparisons as the first two essays analyze well and somewhat deeply and the other two do not.

I feel strongly that students learn literary analysis through study and the doing of the thing. My modeling will only take them so far.

Anyway, here's more instruction.



















Introduction

“Araby” is a short story written by James Joyce; it focuses on an Irish teenage boy who is emerging-from adolescent fantasies into the unkind realities of each day life in his homeland. He doesn’t reveal his identity but he narrates his story in 1st person viewpoint. For readers who are familiar with Joyce’s literary work, it is obvious that he symbolize the author. In the story the boy goes through disillusioning moment that distorts his ideals.

Those experiences alter his viewpoint concerning the world around him. The boy is discovering his deep emotional feelings towards a woman for his first time; he is fantasizing and noticing the women around him. The boy’s involvement with a woman is evident from his fantasies and imagination; he is experiencing intense sexual desires.

Body

The author concentrates largely on his characters instead of the plot to disclose the ironies inbuilt in self-deception. From a different perception, the short story is a commencement of a boy’s pursuit for the ideal. This pursuit however fails but brings about an inner consciousness and a step to adulthood.

From another perspective the short story involves a mature man recalling his experiences: because the short story is narrated in retrospect by a grown man who remembers a specific moment of profound insight and meaning. Per se, the experience of the boy is not limited to youth’s first love encounters. Instead, it is a depiction of an ongoing problem throughout the life: the inappropriateness of the ideal, of the fantasy as one desires it to be, with the drabness of reality. This dual focus; the first experiences of a young boy and a mature man who remembers these experiences create dramatic depiction of a short story.

The character of the boy is obliquely revealed in the opening setting of the short story. He was raised in the back-wash of a vanishing city. Symbolic images portray him to be a person who is insightful to the fact that the vivacity of his city has faded and left remains of empty piousness, the weakest echo of passion, and merely symbolic reminiscences of a vigorous concern for people and God. Even though the young boy can’t understand this rationally, he believes that the street, the city, and Ireland have become dull and self-satisfied. It is a world of religion stagnation, thus, the boy’s viewpoint is very limited. He is uninformed and thus innocent.

Alone, imaginative, and secluded, he lacks the comprehension needed for appraisal and perception (Milesi, 47). He is initially as blind as the world he lives in, but the author prepares the readers for his ultimate understanding arousal by confiscating his blindness with an unconscious rebuttal of the world’s spiritual stagnation. The way of thinking of the boy is also apparent in the opening scenes. Spirituality controls the lives of North Richmond Street people, but it is a fading religion and gets only lip service. However, the boy getting into the new understanding of first love, he discovers his glossary within the experiences of his spiritual training and the passionate tales he has read.

The outcome is a naive and puzzled understanding of love founded on quasi spiritual terms and the descriptions of romance. This fusion of two mythologies, i.e. the Christian with sacrifice and hope symbols and the Oriental with its delicate heroism symbols and escape, combine to create in his mind a deceptive world of spiritual and idyllic beauty.

This combination, which forms an “epiphany” for the young boy as he escorts his aunt through the bazaar, allows the reader to experience with unexpected enlightenment the thoughts and texture of his young mind (Müller, 9). The reader sees the vainness and obstinacy of his quest. He interprets the world blindly through his dreams’ images.

The boy is unusually infatuated, and from his naive romanticism and obduracy. He must wake up to the hassle of the world surrounding him and respond. Hence the first half of the short story foreshadows (as the grown man later comprehends) the awakening and disenchantment of the boy (Books Llc, 48). The boy has gone through so many changes as the author takes us through his boyhood and manhood. His boyhood is filled with great imaginations and fantasies and when he is a grown man he remembers then all realizes all the disillusionments. Most of these changes are taking place in his mind and formed images in his naïve mind.

Conclusion

The story of the boy’s vain quest stresses on his lonely romanticism and his facility to acquire the viewpoints he now has. The pursuit ends when he gets at the marketplace and realizes with gradual, tormented clearness that Araby is not in any way what he expected or imagined. It is gaudy and murky and succeeds on the profit motive and the undying allure its name stirs up in people. The boy realizes that he put all his optimism and love in a world that is not real except in his innocent imagination.

He feels irritated and betrayed and realizes he has been deceiving himself. He thinks he is a being driven and disdained by his own vanity. The man, recalling this surprising experience from his teenage years, remembers the time he understood that living this dream was no longer a possibility. At the end of the short story, Joyce allows the readers to discover “the creature driven and derided by vanity.”

Works Cited

Books Llc. Short Stories by James Joyce: The Sisters, Araby, the Dead, a Painful Case, a Little Cloud, Eveline, Clay, a Mother, an Encounter, New York, General Books LLC, 2010. Print

Müller, Sarah. Adolescence, Love and Sex in James Joyce’s Short Stories “Araby” and “An Encounter,” USA, GRIN Verlag, 2009. Print

Milesi, Laurent. James Joyce and the difference of language, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2003. Print




https://www.ukessays.com/essays/english-literature/literary-analysis-of-james-joyces-araby-english-literature-essay.php

Literary Analysis Of James Joyces Araby English Literature Essay

Info: 1381 words (6 pages) Essay
Published: 1st Jan 2015 in English Literature


In James Joyce’s short story, “Araby”, the speaker’s youthful idealism and naïve fantasies are left shattered when a trip to the bazaar awakens him to the dark realities of his life. The narrator, a nameless adolescent Catholic schoolboy, is living in an oppressive and joyless environment, yet he is able to detach from the frustrating grimness of the surroundings by immersing himself in a confused infatuation for a neighborhood girl. With unrestrained enthusiasm, the boy allows himself to be consumed with foolish lust and adoration for a girl whom he “did not know if ›he would ever speak to” (Araby 112). In truth the girl, sister to the boy’s friend Mangan, is a virtual stranger, but in his mind the boy has transformed the girl into an image worthy of religious devotion. The boy feels as if his feelings for the girl keep him shielded from the hostile and monotonous frustration of Dublin life, almost as if these feelings grant him exalted status and thus separate him from the masses. When the girl finally speaks to the boy she confides that she could not go to the bazaar Araby, and the boy eagerly takes this opportunity to get closer to the object of his immature romanticism by promising that he will go to the bazaar and return with a small memento for her. As he did with the girl, the boy allows his idyllic fantasies to transform his image of the bazaar into something that it is not. The boy envisions Araby as an exotic enchanted place able to somehow grant him the ability to fulfill his quixotic desires. When Araby turns out to be a drab dark place, lacking any of the vitality and exoticness the boy was depending would turn dreams into truth, the boy is faced with the harsh reality that his fantasies are not actuality, and he realizes that his devotion to this uncorroborated image of a girl does not separate him from the bleakness of his everyday life; in fact, the disappointment that is Araby awakens the boy to the fact that his immature dreams have blinded him to the cold and stagnant reality of his ordinary life.

In the descriptions of his surroundings the boy depicts a cold and dark atmosphere devoid of joy and light. The one exemption in this portrait of darkness is Magnan’s sister, whom he portrays as the only source of light in this bleak world. The boy described the street he lived, North Richmond Street, on as “being blind”, the houses of the street as having “brown imperturbable faces”, and the rooms of his own house as being “musty from having been enclosed too long” and “littered with old useless papers” (Joyce 111). These descriptions serve to convey how repressed the boy feels by his stagnant surroundings. In contrast to the hard dark portrait of North Richmond Street, the descriptions of the girl seem riddled with lightness and ease. The image of the girl was always illuminated, whether it was “her figure defined by the light from ›a half-opened door” (Joyce 111) or “the light from the lamp . . . ›lighting up her hair” (Joyce 112), and her every movement, even “the soft rope of her hair ›tossing from side to side” (Joyce 111), suggested a soft easiness. In his mind the boy transformed the image of the girl into an angelic portrait worthy of religious devotion. The boy’s infatuation pervades his every action and he clings to the image of the girl “even in places the most hostile to romance” (Joyce 111), as if his feelings were a “chalice” that could guide him “safely through a throng of foes” (Joyce 112). The boy is blinded to the bleakness of his existence by consuming himself in feelings for the girl, for he believes that his feelings are like a coat of armor that shield him from the oppression and ordinariness of everyday life.

The bazaar Araby, according to the boy’s foolish thoughts, is an opportunity that can bring to life the great love he feels for the image of the girl. He thinks that Araby will be a glimpse of the free and exotic life that is ahead of him, for he believes that his feelings for the girl are leading him down a life path that will separate him from the drabness around him. As he did with the girl, the boy lets his imagination run wild and creates an extraordinary image of Araby in his mind. The boy allows the Araby of his mind’s eye to “cast an Eastern enchantment over ›him”, and, as he had with the girl, allows his every thought to be infused with Araby (Joyce 112). This new obsession further blinds the boy to the monotony of his existence because he now has divine purpose, getting to Araby, and everyday responsibilities can now be brushed aside as “ugly monotonous child’s play” that stand between him and his purpose (Joyce 112). The boy is naively hinging all hopes for creating a different kind of life for himself on a bazaar that exists only in his mind.

The journey to Araby is a foreshadowing of the great disappointment to come. The boy embarks on his quest to Araby by train and seems surprised that the journey does not immediately place him in exotic surroundings; instead, the boy finds himself “in a third-class carriage of a deserted train” that slowly creeps past “ruinous houses” to drop him at an “improvised wooden platform” (Joyce 113). The boy does not let this first disappointment to deter him entering the “would be splendid bazaar” with his high expectations intact, but as soon as he enters the hall that houses Araby he senses that his idyllic fantasies have led him astray (Joyce 112). Instead of being greeted with the hustle and bustle of the exotic, the boy is met with a “silence like that which pervades a church after a service” permeating through a hall bathed in darkness (Joyce 114). This image of silence and darkness is no different than all that surrounds the boy on North Richmond Street, and thus no different from what he is trying to escape. The final disappointment for the boy comes when he approaches a bazaar stall staffed by a disinterested girl with an English accent, and all at once he sees that his dreams of Araby held no truth. The reality of Araby exposes the boy’s fantasies as the foolish desires of an immature “creature driven and derided by vanity” (Joyce 114). This awakening to the fact that his fantasies fooled him make the boy also realize that his intense feelings for the girl, a girl he knows only by looks, are really just based in shallow vanity, leaving the boy “›burning with anguish and anger” (Joyce 114). The anguish the boy feels is most likely in part because he now has no fantasies to escape to, and must face the fact that he is an ordinary boy living a dreary and tedious life


The narrator of “Araby” begins the story as a naïve schoolboy confidently allowing his fantasies to shield him from the stagnant and repetitive life that is his reality. The boy was not afraid to whole-heartedly believe in his whimsy desires, and did not hesitate in thinking that his expectations would not let him down. When the pivotal moment arises and his dreams are not shown to have any basis in realism, the boy is left to angrily face his desolate life. Essentially, attending the bazaar Araby may be the experience that forced a young man to stop living in a fantasy world and start living in reality. Although this story could leave many readers with a sense of sadness and disappointment for a boy whose hopes have been shattered, it left me with a sense of sense of hope. The theme of the story was that one can not hide from the harsh realities of life, but underlying that was a not so obvious theme; that is, a theme of passion and of whole-heartedly striving for what one believes in. The boy chased his fantasy and was harshly let down, but his actions were permeated with passion and ambition. The hope I was left with was the hope that the boy could direct his enthusiasm, passion, and drive towards goals that would take him to a place void of oppression and darkness.

Cite This Work

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:



UKEssays. (November 2018). Literary Analysis Of James Joyces Araby English Literature Essay. Retrieved from https://www.ukessays.com/essays/english-literature/literary-analysis-of-james-joyces-araby-english-literature-essay.php?vref=1


+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

- Bloggery committed by chris tower - 2111.11 - 10:10

- Days ago = 2323 days ago

- New note - On 1807.06, I ceased daily transmission of my Hey Mom feature after three years of daily conversations. I plan to continue Hey Mom posts at least twice per week but will continue to post the days since ("Days Ago") count on my blog each day. The blog entry numbering in the title has changed to reflect total Sense of Doubt posts since I began the blog on 0705.04, which include Hey Mom posts, Daily Bowie posts, and Sense of Doubt posts. Hey Mom posts will still be numbered sequentially. New Hey Mom posts will use the same format as all the other Hey Mom posts; all other posts will feature this format seen here.

No comments: